Monday, February 2, 2026

Vintage Cookery - Spreadable Butter

 


With the current prices of groceries on the rise I thought sharing this WWII tip for “stretching the butter” might be a really good idea.  When butter was rationed smart housewives had to figure out ways to make the most of what they had.  Butter was one of those rationed foods that was a bit hard to come by so when it was advised to stretch it with some evaporated milk I thought that was brilliant.

 


Using your electric mixture you take a pound of softened butter and whip it on low speed while adding a can of evaporated milk to it one tablespoon at a time.  It is a bit tedious and requires some patience because if you add the milk all at once it just makes a soupy mess.  The most important part of the process it to take your time and slowly add the milk to the butter, scraping down the sides of your mixing bowl as needed, until it becomes a big fluffy incorporated bowl of goodness.  Once it is done you simply transfer all of butter mixture into an airtight container and keep it in the refrigerator.  It is nice and spreadable even when cold, melts like butter and even more importantly, it tastes like butter.

 


It takes a pound of butter, 2 cups, and turns it into four cups of whipped butter so if that seems like too much at once, simply cut it in half and only use a cup of butter and half a can of evaporated milk.  I’ve not tried freezing this, but it seems like it might work.  If any of you try this and try freezing it let me know how that works.  Do you think it would be worth doing?

 

 

8 comments:

  1. I don’t believe you could bake with this without adjusting for the increase in moisture, could you?
    If we used a lot of butter for spreading like toast, pancakes, etc., I would try this. But evaporated milk is fairly expensive too.The few cans I have in my pantry were picked up on deep markdown in my baking-almost-every-other-day for school lunches and snacks days. The can which has a markdown price on it was $1.47 for a 12 oz. can)
    That said, I think this might work beautifully for homemade buttercream frosting. (I refuse to use Crisco in mine.) If I bake a cake in the near future I will try this (with the aforementioned can of evaporated milk) and report back to you!
    Have a good week.
    -Meg B.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wouldn't bake with it myself, but in buttercream frosting? I'd give that a try. I won't use Crisco in my frostings either. I typically get evaporated milk for about $1, but I have always just used a stick of butter and to be honest I think I'm too lazy to do this. LOL

      Delete
  2. Oh, I am interested in doing this, especially if it spreads more easily. Since you can also freeze milk, I think it should be ok to freeze this. Will try!

    ReplyDelete
  3. if you are using this as a spread on toast (and not for buttercream frosting) would you add a bit of salt? Since most butter is salted and th evaporated milk would dilute the saltiness?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good point Ginny. I would taste it and see, then add some if needed.

      Delete
  4. I will do this. Long ago had a weight watchers recipe w butter cottage cheese and Butter Buds mixed together.

    ReplyDelete

Your kind comments are always appreciated!
Comment modification has been turned due to spam. I will get your messages up as quickly as possible each day. Thank you for understanding and know I love hearing from you very much.